Below is a short summary and detailed review of this video written by FutureFactual:
Milky Way Andromeda Merger: New Simulations Highlight What Really Determines Our Galaxy's Fate
In this video, an astrophysicist explores the future relationship between the Milky Way and Andromeda, driven by measurements of Andromeda’s approach and large-scale simulations. Doppler-shift observations indicate Andromeda is moving toward us at about 301 kilometers per second, suggesting a collision in a few billion years. However, a new study by Savala and collaborators finds only a 50 percent chance of a merger within 10 billion years, depending on the influence of nearby galaxies like the Large Magellanic Cloud and M33. The analysis shows how the four heaviest Local Group galaxies shape the outcome, with M33 slowing Andromeda and the LMC speeding up the Milky Way relative to Andromeda. Uncertainties remain, and better data from Gaia, Hubble, JWST, and Roman could refine the forecast.
Introduction: The Milky Way and Andromeda at the Edge of Collision
In this video, an enthusiastic astrophysicist shares the enduring fascination with the fate of our galaxy pair. The traditional view that the Milky Way will inevitably collide with Andromeda has captivated scientists and the public alike. The speaker explains that using Doppler shift measurements on light from Andromeda reveals its approach toward the Milky Way at approximately 301 kilometers per second. This velocity suggests a collision could occur in a few billion years, but recent work cautions that this outcome is not guaranteed. The discussion pivots from a simple two-body narrative to a more complex, four-body problem that includes the largest members of our Local Group.
"Proclamations of the impending demise of our galaxy seem greatly exaggerated." - Savala and collaborators.
Section 1: The Local Group and Its Major Players
The Milky Way does not exist in isolation. Surrounding it are dwarf galaxies and two major neighbors, with Andromeda (M31) being the most massive. The Andromeda galaxy itself harbors smaller companions. In addition to Andromeda and the Milky Way, the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) and M33 (the Triangulum Galaxy) are the next most influential Local Group members. The video outlines how these galaxies are distributed, their approximate sizes, and their spatial relationships. The dynamics of these galaxies, not just the Milky Way and Andromeda alone, matter for predicting whether the two giants will merge.
"By including M33, the merger probability goes up to 63 percent." - Savala and collaborators.
Section 2: How We Build the Simulations
To forecast the future, researchers run large-scale simulations that require precise measurements of each galaxy's mass, position, velocity, and the distribution of stars. Data from the Hubble Space Telescope and the Gaia mission provide the best available inputs, though uncertainties remain. Savala and collaborators conducted 50,000 simulations of the four heaviest Local Group galaxies to explore how small changes in initial conditions propagate into very different outcomes over 10 billion years. The goal is to understand not just a single destiny for the Milky Way and Andromeda, but the range of possibilities given what we still do not precisely know about these systems.
"There's actually only a 50 percent chance that the Milky Way and Andromeda will merge in the next 10 billion years." - Savala and collaborators.
Section 3: The Big Influencers: M33 and the Large Magellanic Cloud
The simulations reveal that the four heaviest Local Group galaxies have outsized effects on the future path of the Milky Way and Andromeda. Including M33 in the model increases the merger probability to about 63 percent, while including the LMC can lower this probability by altering the relative speeds of the two giants. The key mechanism is kinetic: M33 slows Andromeda relative to the Milky Way, whereas the LMC speeds up the Milky Way relative to Andromeda. When these velocity changes accumulate, they determine whether gravity can ultimately slosh the two galaxies into a merger or simply allow them to pass by each other. In short, the fate depends on how these neighbors shape the timing and geometry of their approach.
"Adding M33 increases the merger probability to 63 percent." - Savala and collaborators.
Section 4: What All This Means for the Notion of a Galactic Merger
The results shift the conversation from a fixed prediction to a probabilistic forecast that accounts for uncertain inputs and the influence of neighboring galaxies. If the LMC speeds up the Milky Way relative to Andromeda, the two may simply swing past each other with no lasting merger; if M33 slows Andromeda, the odds of a future collision improve. The study concludes that while the Local Group dynamics do not guarantee a Milky Way Andromeda merger, the two galaxies will likely become one at some point in time if the other major members captured or merged with them first. The presentation emphasizes that even with the four-heaviest galaxies included, the outcome remains sensitive to precise values for mass, velocity, and position.
"The Large Magellanic Cloud speeds up the Milky Way relative to Andromeda, and Andromeda is affected by M33, which adds a degree of chaos to its path." - Savala and collaborators.
Section 5: Data Uncertainty and the Path Forward
One of the core messages is that our understanding is only as good as our data. Uncertainties in 22 parameters are propagated through the simulations, and the differences between including or excluding certain neighbors lead to meaningful shifts in the predicted outcome. The video highlights the need for improved measurements in the Gaia data for the Milky Way and Large Magellanic Cloud, plus better observations of M33 and Andromeda with Hubble, the James Webb Space Telescope, and perhaps Roman. With tighter constraints on the initial conditions, the simulations can be rerun to yield a clearer picture of what the next few billion years hold for our galaxy pair.
"We need better data from Gaia, Hubble, JWST and Roman to reduce uncertainties." - Savala and collaborators.
Conclusion: The Future of Our Galactic Neighborhood
The takeaway is not a definitive proclamation that the Milky Way will definitely merge with Andromeda, but rather a nuanced, probabilistic assessment that depends on the full roster of Local Group dynamics. As data improve, the range of likely outcomes will narrow, and the scientific consensus will become more precise. The video closes by reminding viewers that the cosmos is a intricate, interconnected system where many bodies influence each other over cosmic timescales. In the end, the core message is that the fate of our galaxy is not sealed, and the question invites ongoing observation and modeling to better understand our place in the universe.
"Proclamations of the impending demise of our galaxy seem greatly exaggerated." - Savala and collaborators.