Beta

How can a photon have momentum?

Below is a short summary and detailed review of this video written by FutureFactual:

Why Photons Have Momentum: The Energy Momentum Relation Explained

Short summary

In this video, a physics educator tackles the puzzle of photon momentum. Starting from familiar momentum and energy equations, the talk shows that momentum does not vanish for photons even though their mass is zero. By invoking the general energy momentum relation E^2 = (pc)^2 + (mc^2)^2, the presenter derives that for a photon (m = 0) we have E = pc, so momentum p = E/c. The discussion also emphasizes that equations like P = mv are approximations valid only for objects with mass moving slowly, and that mass can be viewed as a form of energy. The result is a deeper understanding of how moving energy carries momentum and why physics is about energy in motion across regimes.

  • Why P = mv fails for photons
  • The universal energy momentum relation
  • Mass as energy and photon momentum intuition
  • Physics as energy in motion

Introduction

The video opens with a common physics question: how can a photon, which has no mass, carry momentum? The presenter notes that momentum is often introduced via the equation P = mv, which seems to imply photons should have zero momentum because their mass is zero. The discussion sets up a broader view: classical equations are approximations that work only for objects with mass at slow speeds, and a more general framework is required for massless or highly relativistic objects.

The Limits of Classical Momentum

The speaker walks through the classic momentum relation P = mv and shows how, when squared, it ties into kinetic energy ke = 1/2 mv^2. He demonstrates how ke is related to momentum through ke = p^2 / (2m). This classical connection suggests a link between energy and momentum even in Newtonian physics, but it also reveals that the simple p = mv form cannot apply to massless particles like photons. The key point is that the classical formulas are limited to objects with mass moving much slower than light.

The General Energy Momentum Relation

To address the photon puzzle, the video introduces a more general relation that holds in all circumstances: E^2 = (pc)^2 + (mc^2)^2. This equation reduces to familiar forms in the appropriate limits. It shows that energy and momentum are fundamentally linked, and mass is not a prerequisite for having energy or momentum. In the photon case where m = 0, the equation reduces to E = pc, or p = E/c, which aligns with the idea that light carries momentum even though it has no rest mass.

Photon Case and Massless Momentum

With the mass term vanishing, the photon momentum is directly proportional to its energy. The presenter emphasizes that energy and momentum are not exclusive to massive particles: any moving energy packet, including photons, has momentum. The video contrasts this with E = mc^2, which remains an approximate relation for objects with mass and does not generalize to massless or fast-moving cases. This distinction helps dissolve the apparent paradox about a massless particle having momentum.

The Mass Illusion and Energy Perspective

Beyond the equations, the talk challenges the notion of mass as a fundamental, immutable property. It is argued that mass can be viewed as a manifestation of energy, and that the true, universal description of motion is through energy and momentum rather than mass alone. The presenter points to a broader view of modern physics in which mass emerges from the dynamics of energy rather than being an intrinsic substance. This perspective is reinforced by discussing how subatomic constituents contribute to the mass of composite objects, with mass arising largely from motion and energy of internal components rather than from rest mass alone.

Intuition and Physical Consequences

The video then builds more intuitive pictures, explaining radiation pressure and momentum transfer from light to matter. It draws connections to everyday and astronomical phenomena, such as solar sails, which rely on photon momentum to exert force on spacecraft. The discussion emphasizes that momentum is not a property that only massive particles possess; moving energy, including electromagnetic fields, can carry and transfer momentum.

Conclusions and Takeaways

In summary, the speaker concludes that photons do carry momentum, but not via the classical P = mv relation. The correct, universal description is the energy momentum relation E^2 = (pc)^2 + (mc^2)^2, which for photons reduces to E = pc. The talk reinforces the idea that equations are valid only in their domains, and as physics deepens, concepts like mass and energy reveal a more nuanced and interconnected structure. The video closes with a call to appreciate the unity of energy and momentum across all physical regimes and to view physics as the exploration of moving energy in all its forms.

To find out more about the video and Fermilab go to: How can a photon have momentum?.

Related posts

featured
Fermilab
·25/07/2022

Kinetic energy: Newton vs. Einstein | Who's right?

featured
MIT OpenCourseWare
·05/07/2017

Compton Scattering