To read the original article in full go to : Were Denisovans tall compared to other ancient humans? We should be sceptical.
Below is a short summary and detailed review of this article written by FutureFactual:
Penghu Denisovan Bones Hint at Tall Hominins: Height Estimates from the Taiwan Strait Seafloor
The Conversation reports a new study that estimates the stature of two Denisovans from long bones dredged from the Penghu Channel, Taiwan Strait. By comparing femur and tibia sizes, the researchers infer tall individual heights for Penghu 2 and Penghu 3, but they caution that without secure context, it is risky to generalize about Denisovan height as a species trait. Here is a quick take on what was found and why it matters.
- Denisovans from Penghu Channel likely tall, with Penghu 2 about 1.8 m (roughly 5'11") and Penghu 3 about 1.9 m (around 6'3").
- Long bones (femur and tibia) used to estimate height; preserved proteins help assign the bones to Denisovans despite DNA loss.
- Context is limited because discovery locations and geological provenance were not recorded, making precise dating ambiguous (Middle to Late Pleistocene, 2.58 million to 11,700 years ago).
- Headlines about Denisovans being unusually tall should be treated with skepticism until more contextual data are available.
- Author: The Conversation
Overview
The Conversation discusses a fossil-based height reconstruction study of Denisovans using two incomplete long bones—a femur and a tibia—recovered from the Penghu Channel in the Taiwan Strait. The bones were dredged from the seabed, not excavated in a controlled context, which complicates dating and stratigraphic association. Nevertheless, analyses of preserved proteins (paleoproteomics) and comparative anatomy enabled researchers to assign the bones to Denisovans and to estimate their stature by scaling whole-bone size from the leg elements. The study contributes to the broader discussion of how tall Denisovans were, but it also highlights the limits of inferring population-wide traits from just two individuals.




