To read the original article in full go to : What lurks Below Newfoundland waters? A marine biologist explains the science behind the show.
Below is a short summary and detailed review of this article written by FutureFactual:
Below the Giant Squid: Newfoundland Oceanography, Folklore and Science in Netflix's Below
Netflix's Below features a sea monster terrorizing a Newfoundland outport, and this review uses the island's ocean history to evaluate the show's science, setting and narrative. The author notes the way the drama anchors itself in real places like the Oceans Sciences Centre and The Rooms provincial museum, while weaving Newfoundland culture, the cod-fishery legacy, and resettlement history into the storyline. While some monster-driven fiction stretches credibility, the piece acknowledges strong attempts to portray marine biology, ocean physics and ecological complexity. The review closes by highlighting the potential for such storytelling to foster public interest in ocean science and exploration, and it situates the discussion within the broader Newfoundland ocean-history context. The Conversation
- Fresh Newfoundland context grounds marine biology plausibility
- Historical elements such as northern cod collapse and resettlement shape the plot
- Giant squid biology and cephalopod capabilities are discussed with realism and limits
- The show has the potential to spark public interest in ocean science
Overview
Below the Netflix miniseries follows a sea monster threatening a Newfoundland outport, and the author uses this narrative to reflect on how a coastal, science-focused setting can illuminate ocean life and history. The piece emphasizes four reasons the Newfoundland setting matters: it is the reviewer’s home region, the author has studied local oceanography for most of their career, the show features a marine lab and a real research institution, and the creature at the center echoes the iconic giant squid that has long haunted both folklore and science in the area.
The reviewer argues that, despite the horror genre’s appetite for sensational conflict, Below generally succeeds in presenting marine biology with plausible detail while still delivering excitement. The biology of the giant squid is described as reasonably plausible, including its swimming capabilities and ability to survive in icy water, with some stretch toward behavioral sophistication that the reviewer treats as a cinematic concession rather than a claim about real cephalopod cognition. The piece notes that cephalopod research has yielded remarkable capabilities in recent decades, suggesting that the show’s imagined intelligence and vengeful behavior are entertaining but not wholly outside the realm of possibility within the context of cephalopod biology.
Newfoundland as a living laboratory
The author repeatedly returns to local geography and history to ground the series in a tangible context. The Oceans Sciences Centre at Memorial University serves as a backdrop for the science, while the provincial museum, The Rooms, hosts a preserved giant squid that anchors regional fascination with these animals. Historical moments—such as Moses Harvey’s 19th-century giant squid photograph, Fred Aldrich’s 1960s work at the Oceans Sciences Centre, and the recurring theme of Newfoundland’s outport resilience—are treated as essential scaffolding for understanding how science and culture intersect in this coastal region. The article also highlights Newfoundland-specific narratives, including the northern cod collapse that devastated communities and the government-sponsored resettlement of coastal populations in the mid-20th century, which are woven into the show’s plot and mood.
Historical accuracy and local flavor
The reviewer reflects on their own education in marine invertebrates, recalling Fred Aldrich’s enthusiasm for giant squid research and appreciating how the miniseries nods to actual milestones, such as the first live footage of giant squid in the wild. The article situates these moments within a broader timeline that includes Harvey’s shore-based photograph that introduced the species to European science, lending weight to the idea that Newfoundland’s ocean history is a legitimate lens for evaluating the show’s science. The review emphasizes that the series’ Newfoundland ambience—its accents, geography, cultural touchstones like the Screeching In ceremony, and the region’s historical traumas—adds depth to the storytelling and makes the science more engaging for audiences who might not otherwise seek out oceanography.
Science plausibility and limits
While the biology of the giant squid is plausibly depicted, the review notes that the miniseries pushes the creature’s intellectual prowess and directed vindictiveness beyond what current cephalopod science would typically predict. The article cites researchers who document impressive cephalopod abilities while maintaining a skeptical eye on how those abilities are portrayed on screen. Still, the reviewer lauds the show for balancing scientific plausibility with entertainment value and for foregrounding ocean life as a star character rather than merely a backdrop for horror. The piece also comments on practical production choices, such as how the Coast Guard’s response to an isolated crisis on a small island is portrayed, inviting viewers to consider the real-world challenges of crisis management in remote communities.
Stoking interest in the ocean
The author argues that the series’ success and its Newfoundland setting have the potential to inspire a new generation of ocean scientists. By highlighting ongoing opportunities for ocean exploration and the discovery of new marine life in the deep sea, the review frames Below as more than a sensational horror story; it is a reminder of how much remains unknown beneath the waves and how a gripping narrative can spark public curiosity about science. The author suggests a path for future projects: tell ocean stories that are thrilling but grounded in real-world science, anchored by credible institutions and local histories, to motivate viewers to learn more about the ocean and consider pursuingrelated careers.
Conclusion
Overall, the review affirms that Below, while primarily a horror-adventure, makes a meaningful contribution by connecting Newfoundland’s ocean history with current cephalopod science. It notes that the film’s Newfoundland ambience—along with references to resettlement, the cod fishery collapse, and local governance—gives the series emotional and historical weight. The piece closes with a hopeful call for more ocean-focused storytelling that leverages AI-assisted content curation to bring credible, cross-media science content to living rooms worldwide. The Conversation
